Mixed Signals from the Universe

Who here has ever fudged a number to get the answer they wanted?

Chapter 1

1917
1998
2025

Is the Universe standing still?

Berlin, 1917

General Relativity

↓

The Universe can’t stay static

The Fudge

Einstein adds one term

↓
A static Universe

Theory can only take you so far.

How can you tell if a galaxy is moving?

The Doppler effect

Coming toward you: waves get squeezed

Higher pitchBluer light

Moving away: waves get stretched

Lower pitchRedder light

California, 1929

Edwin Hubble

Light from most galaxies is redshifted

The Universe is expanding!

Einstein drops Λ

“Biggest blunder of his life”

Chapter 2

1917
1998
2025

70 years later…

Where is the expansion headed?

Now, a question for everyone

A ball thrown up slows down, because Earth’s gravity pulls it back.

Galaxies are flying apart, while gravity tries to pull them back. So what happens to their speed?

Slows down
Stays the same
Speeds up

The big surprise

1998

Speeding up!

The expansion of the Universe is accelerating

Something is pushing. We call it dark energy.

Saul Perlmutter
Brian Schmidt
Adam Riess
Nobel Prize in Physics · 2011
Photos: Lawrence Berkeley National Lab; Belinda Pratten, ANU; Scanpix/AFP

1There’s a lot of it

95%still a mystery
5%Everything we can seestars, planets, gas, you
27%Dark matter
68%Dark energy
xkcd

2It doesn’t change with time

Universe now
Universe later
Matter
→
Gets dilutedIts total energy stays the same, so it spreads thinner
Dark energy
→
Never dilutedEvery cubic meter always holds the same energy

As space grows, dark energy wins, and the expansion speeds up.

That’s Einstein’s Λ. His “biggest blunder” wasn’t one after all.

Chapter 3

1917
1998
2025

Mapping 11 billion years

To test Einstein’s Λ, we need to watch the Universe grow.

Me with the Mayall Telescope
Me with the Mayall Telescope, Kitt Peak, AZ
The experiment

DESI

Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument

~900scientists
~70institutions
DESI collaborationDESI collaboration meeting, Berkeley, 2025

DESI makes a 3D map of the Universe

47 milliongalaxies and quasars mapped
11 billion yearsback in time: looking far away means seeing the past
5,000robotic “eyes,” built right here at U‑M

DESI 3D map

Map: DESI Collaboration / NOIRLab

But how does a map help?

Animation: CAASTRO

A cosmic ruler

Galaxies have a favorite distance from each other

~500 million
light‑years

about 5,000 Milky Ways, end to end

Measure that ruler across cosmic time, and you learn how fast the Universe grew

And what did we find?

The New York TimesApr 2024
A Tantalizing ‘Hint’ That Astronomers Got Dark Energy All Wrong
NatureMar 2025
Is dark energy getting weaker? Fresh data bolster shock finding
The GuardianMar 2025
Dark energy: mysterious cosmic force appears to be weakening, say scientists
Physics WorldApr 2025
DESI delivers a cosmological bombshell
CNNApr 2025
‘Another mind-blowing change’: New data suggests mysterious dark energy is evolving
Quanta MagazineMar 2025
Is Dark Energy Getting Weaker? New Evidence Strengthens the Case
NPRMar 2025
Dark energy is weakening and the universe could (eventually) collapse, study says
AFPMar 2025
Dark energy seems to be changing, rattling our view of universe
The New York TimesMar 2025
More Than a Hint That Dark Energy Isn’t What Astronomers Thought

Dark energy might be changing with time.

Einstein’s Λ may be in danger. Again.

How sure are we?

3.2σDESI today
HHHHHHHHHH
Like flipping 10 heads in a row~1 in 1,000 chance it’s a fluke
5σA discovery
HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Like flipping 22 heads in a row~1 in 3.5 million

Exciting, but not a discovery yet.

With great results comes great scrutiny

2,007papers citing DESI’s 2025 result in 20 months.
That’s about 3 every day.
42%build a new theory of dark energy
14%test or question it
44%use DESI’s map for other science

Where my own papers land

Not me. I test theories more than I build them.
“Expansion-history preferences of DESI DR2 and external data”2025“Transient early reionization allows for a high optical depth…”2026
“Difficulties with late-time solutions for the Hubble tension”2026“FolpsD: combining EFT and phenomenological approaches…”2026
INSPIRE citations of DESI DR2 BAO. Split from the titles of a ~500-paper sample, sorted by Claude.

The jury is still out

1

A second opinion

The Dark Energy Survey, a different telescope and team, sees a similar hint in its final data.

2

More data coming

DESI keeps mapping into 2028, and new telescopes like Rubin and Euclid will weigh in.

Subway Takes

The Universe surprised us three times

1917It’s expanding
1998It’s speeding up
2025Dark energy might be changing?

Einstein’s “blunder” might be a blunder after all.

Not a discovery yet. More data, and plenty of skeptics, will decide.

Astronomy on Tap

Thank you!

Questions? Come chat.

prakharb@umich.edu

QR code

Do real astronomy from your couchRubin Observatory projects on Zooniverse
zooniverse.org/rubin